Step 11 of 18 · Worked example · TEACH
0 of 3 done
Work through the example to CHECK to open the problems.
Reach CHECK to open the problems.Higher Level · Statistics · Step 11Say what each design can conclude, and why.
Researchers report that students who eat breakfast score higher in tests. They then design a study where 200 volunteers are randomly assigned either a provided breakfast or no breakfast for a term. Compare the conclusions each study supports.
What each study can conclude
| Study | Design | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|
| Study 1 | Observe who eats breakfast | Association only |
| Study 2 | Randomly assign breakfast | Causation (for volunteers) |
| Limit | Both | Volunteers may not represent all |
Study 1: researchers report that students who eat breakfast score higher in tests.
Study 2: 200 volunteers are randomly assigned breakfast or no breakfast for a term.
Compare the conclusions each study supports.
Higher Level Maths · Statistics & Probability · Step 11 of 18
Only a designed experiment with randomised allocation supports a cause-and-effect claim; an observational study can only report association.
The strongest available conclusion depends entirely on how the data were produced, and that is a marked part of exam answers.
Study 1: researchers report that students who eat breakfast score higher in tests. Study 2: 200 volunteers are randomly assigned breakfast or no breakfast for a term. Compare the conclusions each study supports.
sample survey · observational study · designed experiment · randomisation · control group · confounding · ethics