Step 8 of 15 · Worked example · TEACH

← Statistics & Probability

0 of 3 done

Work through the example to CHECK to open the problems.

Reach CHECK to open the problems.Ordinary Level · Statistics · Step 8

Classify the study and state the type of conclusion it supports.

A company tests whether a new fertiliser increases plant growth by randomly assigning plants to a fertiliser group or a no-fertiliser group, then measuring growth after 4 weeks. Identify the type of study and what it can conclude.

Experiment vs observation

FeatureDesigned experimentObservational study
Treatment assigned?Yes, randomlyNo
ConclusionCausationAssociation only
Who is studied picked at random?Allowed, but it is not what makes an experimentStill observational
Random assignment of a treatment is the key feature of a designed experiment.

A company tests whether a new fertiliser increases plant growth.

Plants are randomly assigned to a fertiliser group or a no fertiliser group.

Growth is measured after 4 weeks.

Identify the type of study and what it can conclude.

Read it once, slowly. Then copy it onto your page.
  • What is going on? One question: does the new fertiliser make plants grow more?
  • The key words: plants are randomly assigned. Chance decides which plants go in the fertiliser group and which go in the group with none.
  • Both groups are measured after 4 weeks, so they can be compared.
  • What do they want? Two things in words: the type of study, and what it can conclude.
Céim

Ordinary Level Maths · Statistics & Probability · Step 8 of 15

Surveys, Observational Studies & Designed Experiments

A designed experiment randomly assigns a treatment and can support a causal conclusion; an observational study only records what already happens and can show association at most.

Why it matters

Mixing these up leads to claiming 'X causes Y' from evidence that only ever showed X and Y occurring together.

The worked example

A company tests whether a new fertiliser increases plant growth. Plants are randomly assigned to a fertiliser group or a no fertiliser group. Growth is measured after 4 weeks. Identify the type of study and what it can conclude.

How the worked example goes

  1. Read

    • What is going on? One question: does the new fertiliser make plants grow more?
    • The key words: plants are randomly assigned. Chance decides which plants go in the fertiliser group and which go in the group with none.
    • Both groups are measured after 4 weeks, so they can be compared.
  2. Understand

    • What kinds of study are there?
    • Survey
    • Ask people questions and record their answers.
  3. Reduce

    • Which fact decides the type of study? Who assigns the fertiliser: If the researcher assigns the treatment, it is an experiment. If nobody does, it is observational.
    • What do I do?
    • 1. Find the treatment, and who assigned it.
  4. Solve

    • What type of study is it?
    • Treatment: the fertiliser.
    • The company assigns it, and chance decides which plants get it.
  5. Check

    • Is it right?
    • Treatment assigned by chance? Yes ✓
    • Control group to compare with? Yes ✓

Common mistakes to avoid

Key terms

designed experiment · observational study · random assignment · causation · correlation