Step 9 of 9 · Worked example · TEACH

← Nature of Science & Investigation Reasoning

0 of 3 done

Work through the example to CHECK to open the problems.

Reach CHECK to open the problems.Ordinary Level · Chemistry · Nature of Science & Investigation Reasoning · Step 9

Follow the worked example. At each stage, explain why the next step is justified.

An advert says a cleaning spray 'kills 99 % of germs' but gives no details of how this was tested. What questions should you ask?

An advert says a cleaning spray 'kills 99 % of germs'.

It gives no details of how this was tested.

What questions should you ask?

Read it once, slowly. Then copy it onto your page.
  • What is the claim? Kills 99 % of germs, made in an advert by the people selling the spray.
  • What is missing? No details of the test: no method, no germs named, no tester named.
  • What do they want? The questions you should ask before believing it.
Céim

Ordinary Level Chemistry · Nature of Science & Investigation Reasoning · Step 9 of 9

Sources claims and scientific communication

Before believing a claim, a scientist asks what the evidence is, how it was collected, and whether others have checked it.

Why it matters

Questions ask you to judge claims in adverts or reports, and to explain why scientists share and check each other's work.

The worked example

An advert says a cleaning spray 'kills 99 % of germs'. It gives no details of how this was tested. What questions should you ask?

How the worked example goes

  1. Read

    • What is the claim? Kills 99 % of germs, made in an advert by the people selling the spray.
    • What is missing? No details of the test: no method, no germs named, no tester named.
    • What do they want? The questions you should ask before believing it.
  2. Understand

    • What would make me believe it?
    • A claim needs evidence: results from a test that others can check.
    • Trap: being in an advert does not make it true. Being a famous brand is not evidence either.
  3. Reduce

    • Which question should come first? How was it tested?: Without the method, nobody can check the 99 % claim.
    • Where do I start?
    • Method first: how, and on which germs. Then the testers: who, and did anyone else check it.
  4. Solve

    • Write the answer.
    • 1. How was the test done, and which germs were tested?
    • 2. Who did the test? Were they independent of the company?
  5. Check

    • Is it right?
    • Each question asks about the evidence, not the advert ✓
    • If the company tested it, it is not independent: it sells the spray. That is why "who" matters ✓

Common mistakes to avoid

Key terms

claim · evidence · fair test · checked by others