Step 6 of 9 · Worked example · TEACH

← Nature of Science & Investigation Reasoning

0 of 3 done

Work through the example to CHECK to open the problems.

Reach CHECK to open the problems.Ordinary Level · Chemistry · Nature of Science & Investigation Reasoning · Step 6

Follow the worked example. At each stage, explain why the next step is justified.

A student times how long a cross takes to disappear, but does each temperature only once. Suggest an improvement and explain why it helps.

A student times how long a cross takes to disappear.

Each temperature is tested only once.

Suggest an improvement and explain why it helps.

Read it once, slowly. Then copy it onto your page.
  • What is going on? A cross under the flask slowly fades from view. The student times it by eye, at different temperatures.
  • What is the weak spot? Each temperature is tested only once. The question points straight at it.
  • What do they want? Two things: an improvement, and why it helps.
Céim

Ordinary Level Chemistry · Nature of Science & Investigation Reasoning · Step 6 of 9

Evaluating method & identifying limitations

To improve an experiment, find exactly what went wrong or what was weak, explain how it affected the results, and suggest a change that fixes that problem.

Why it matters

Questions ask you to suggest improvements. Saying 'be more careful' gets no marks; you must name a specific problem and a specific fix.

The worked example

A student times how long a cross takes to disappear. Each temperature is tested only once. Suggest an improvement and explain why it helps.

How the worked example goes

  1. Read

    • What is going on? A cross under the flask slowly fades from view. The student times it by eye, at different temperatures.
    • What is the weak spot? Each temperature is tested only once. The question points straight at it.
    • What do they want? Two things: an improvement, and why it helps.
  2. Understand

    • Why is one test a problem?
    • Timing by eye varies: one try you stop the clock a little early, the next a little late. That is random error.
    • With only one result, a timing slip looks just like a real result. Nothing to check it against.
  3. Reduce

    • Which improvement is best? Repeat each 3 times: It fixes the weakness: now each temperature has more than one result.
    • Where do I start?
    • Write the change, then the reason: what repeating lets you see that one test can't.
  4. Solve

    • Write the answer.
    • Improvement: repeat each temperature at least three times, and work out the mean time.
    • Why: with three results, an odd one stands out and can be checked.
  5. Check

    • Is it right?
    • The fix matches the weakness: one test each, so repeat ✓
    • Trap: repeats only reduce random error. A systematic error, the same each time, stays in.

Common mistakes to avoid

Key terms

improvement · weakness · reliable · heat loss