Step 9 of 9 · Worked example · TEACH

← Nature of Science & Investigation Reasoning

0 of 3 done

Work through the example to CHECK to open the problems.

Reach CHECK to open the problems.Higher Level · Chemistry · Nature of Science & Investigation Reasoning · Step 9

Follow the worked example. At each stage, explain why the next step is justified.

A manufacturer says its treatment halves the concentration of a pollutant, but gives no method and no untreated comparison. Give two questions a scientist would ask.

A manufacturer says its treatment halves the concentration of a pollutant.

It gives no method and no untreated comparison.

Give two questions a scientist would ask.

Read it once, slowly. Then copy it onto your page.
  • What is the claim? The treatment halves the concentration of a pollutant. A manufacturer says so: the company selling it.
  • What is missing? No method: we do not know how it was measured. No untreated comparison: we do not know what happens without it.
  • What do they want? Two questions a scientist would ask: questions that test whether the claim holds up.
Céim

Higher Level Chemistry · Nature of Science & Investigation Reasoning · Step 9 of 9

Sources claims and scientific communication

Scientific claims should be judged by their evidence: the method used, a suitable control or comparison, the data and uncertainties, and whether the result has been reproduced independently.

Why it matters

Questions ask what to look for in a claim, how repeatability differs from reproducibility, and what a report must include so others can check it.

The worked example

A manufacturer says its treatment halves the concentration of a pollutant. It gives no method and no untreated comparison. Give two questions a scientist would ask.

How the worked example goes

  1. Read

    • What is the claim? The treatment halves the concentration of a pollutant. A manufacturer says so: the company selling it.
    • What is missing? No method: we do not know how it was measured. No untreated comparison: we do not know what happens without it.
    • What do they want? Two questions a scientist would ask: questions that test whether the claim holds up.
  2. Understand

    • Why does the method matter?
    • "Halved" is a measurement: concentration before, concentration after. If we do not know how it was measured, no one can check it or repeat it.
    • Every measurement has an uncertainty. Made-up numbers: a fall from 10 to 5 means little if each reading could be out by 4.
  3. Reduce

    • Which question tests whether the treatment caused the fall? What did an untreated sample do?: A control under the same conditions shows whether the fall happens without the treatment.
    • Where do I start?
    • Aim one question at each gap the question names: the missing method, and the missing comparison.
  4. Solve

    • First question: the method.
    • Question 1: how was the concentration measured, and with what uncertainty?
    • This lets someone check the measurement and see whether "half" is bigger than the uncertainty.
  5. Check

    • Is it right?
    • Without a control, the fall might have happened with no treatment at all. Question 2 exposes that ✓
    • Without a method, no one can check or repeat the measurement. Question 1 exposes that ✓

Common mistakes to avoid

Key terms

control · repeatability · reproducibility · peer review