Step 6 of 9 · Worked example · TEACH

← Nature of Science & Investigation Reasoning

0 of 3 done

Work through the example to CHECK to open the problems.

Reach CHECK to open the problems.Higher Level · Chemistry · Nature of Science & Investigation Reasoning · Step 6

Follow the worked example. At each stage, explain why the next step is justified.

In a rate experiment, the end point is judged by eye, and each condition is run only once. Evaluate the method and propose targeted improvements.

In a rate experiment, the end point is judged by eye.

Each condition is run only once.

Evaluate the method and propose targeted improvements.

Read it once, slowly. Then copy it onto your page.
  • What is going on? A rate experiment: time how long a reaction takes to reach an end point. Here the end point is judged by eye, e.g. when a cross vanishes.
  • What else? Each condition is run only once: one reading at each temperature or concentration.
  • What do they want? Evaluate: name the weaknesses and their effects. Then improvements, each targeted at one weakness.
Céim

Higher Level Chemistry · Nature of Science & Investigation Reasoning · Step 6 of 9

Evaluating method & identifying limitations

A method is evaluated by identifying the specific weaknesses that limit the reliability or validity of the results, and proposing improvements that target each weakness.

Why it matters

Evaluation questions want a named weakness, its effect on the results and a specific improvement; general comments such as 'be more careful' earn no marks.

The worked example

In a rate experiment, the end point is judged by eye. Each condition is run only once. Evaluate the method and propose targeted improvements.

How the worked example goes

  1. Read

    • What is going on? A rate experiment: time how long a reaction takes to reach an end point. Here the end point is judged by eye, e.g. when a cross vanishes.
    • What else? Each condition is run only once: one reading at each temperature or concentration.
    • What do they want? Evaluate: name the weaknesses and their effects. Then improvements, each targeted at one weakness.
  2. Understand

    • What goes wrong when I judge by eye?
    • Two people watching the same flask stop the clock at different moments. Even one person varies run to run.
    • Errors that scatter the results up and down by chance are random errors. Judging by eye adds them to every timing.
  3. Reduce

    • Where do I start?
    • Evaluating a method follows the same three steps for every weakness.
    • 1. Name the weakness.
  4. Solve

    • Which change targets judging the end point by eye? Use a light sensor: A light sensor or colorimeter detects the end point the same way every run, removing the judgement.
    • First weakness: by eye.
    • 1. Weakness: judging the end point by eye is subjective.
  5. Check

    • Is it right?
    • Each improvement matches one weakness: sensor ↔ by eye; repeats ↔ one run ✓
    • Both make results more repeatable, more reliable. Neither changes what is measured, so the test's validity is unchanged.

Common mistakes to avoid

Key terms

reliability · validity · limitation · targeted improvement